A motivational analysis of defensive pessimism and selfhandicapping. Psychoanalytic pessimism versus humanistic optimism. The world really seems to be riding the wave of optimism these days. The relationship between optimismpessimism and personality traits among students in the hashemite university ahmad m. Ap psychology chapter personality flashcards quizlet. Defensive pessimism and goal setting via sapientiae depaul. Optimism, pessimism, locus of control, and sensation seeking allen r. Batayeneh3 1 department of educational psychology, faculty of educational science, hashemite university, jordan. Journal of personality and social psychology, 52, 12081217. Comparison of perspectives on personality posted on 12082015 12082015 by gspsychology psychology, possibly more than any other science, in its comparatively short history has been in the heat of the battle between opposing theories, most notably, freudian psychodynamic theory and radical. Journal of personality and social personality, 65, 822835. Theories of personality view of the causes and motives underlying. Psychometric evaluation of the turkish version of the defensive. Defensive pessimism is a strategy used by anxious people to help them manage their anxiety so they can work productively.
Article pdf available in the journal of psychology interdisciplinary and applied 1433. After item valence was controlled, we did not replicate marshall et al. Then, they mentally play through all the bad things that might happen. Do optimism and pessimism have different relationships with. Pdf a twofactor model of defensive pessimism and its relations. Most events in your life are neutral, like driving your car or getting the mail from your mailbox, but it is your attitude that will define your experience. Personality 3 personalities seep out in almost everything we do. You put all the optimists on one side and all the pessimists on the other lets leave the realists aside for now. Three components of anticipatory strategies expectations, anxiety, and extent of preparation were assessed at three times over the course of. However, there is variability in students law school academic. Norem and cantor 1989 highlight defensive pessimism as a coping style, which focuses around a specific context.
Personality psychology psychological research methods. Norem 2 and nancy cantor university of michigan the concept of cognitive strategies is proposed as a model for the process by which individuals cushion themselves against threats to selfesteem in. A specific type of pessimism called defensive pes simism has also focused research on the differences between optimism and pessimism 10, defensive pes simism is different from dispositional. Journal of personality and social psychology, 701, 141156. The conclusion considers the implications that defensive pessimism has for how people. Her book on defensive pessimism, the positive power of negative thinking basic books was published in 2001. Highlights the current research reexamined marshall et al. Norem, phd, a professor of psychology at wellesley college. Defensive pessimism is a cognitive strategy identified by nancy cantor and her students in the. Her research has been published in top journals, such as the journal of personality and social psychology and books such as the handbook of.
Pdf the positive psychology of negative thinking julie norem. Jul 08, 2018 imagine you divided everyone in the world into two psychological groups. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. Defensive pessimism psychology definition iresearchnet.
In response to those feelings, they set pessimistic expectations about how things will go, and they mentally rehearse all the things they. Pessimism is always living as if the cup is half empty, not half full. While pessimism is often seen as a negative trait, defensive pessimism can be a useful way for someone to harness their anxiety into positive results. Anticipatory thoughts and feelings of defensively pessimistic and moderately depressed college students were compared in order to identify factors that distinguish effective strategies of negative thinking from those that may be maladaptive. Journal of personality and social psychology, 45, 1276. It feels a little awkward to admit that im a pessimist. New to this edition, personality and the brain coverage throughout the text shows readers how cuttingedge advances in neuroscience inform all aspects of personality theory and research.
Her 2002 book on the topic is maybe not quite as famous as peales, but perhaps it will catch on if the debbie downers. Individuals who use defensive pessimism set low expectations, and play through extensive mental simulations of possible outcomes as they prepare for goal. Defensive pessimism was first defined by norem and cantor 1986b as a cognitive strategy that involves. In this way, the strategies of defensivepessimism and generation of positive expectations have. Persons who believe that their goals can be achieved despite the difficulties they might encounter are said to hold an optimistic view. Death and dying the enneagram and psychology evolutionary psychology. An invaluable resource for over four decades, personality examines the fundamental theories and concepts of personality psychology while exploring contemporary research, new methodologies, and the latest technological advancements. Social and personality psychology compass, 2, 1214. Defensive pessimism how negative thinking can pay off. The power of introverts in a world that cant stop talking by susan cain, gifts differing. Defensive pessimists dps, who set low expectations, feel anxious, and rehearse. What do we know about personality from the idiographic approach. Norem joined the faculty at wellesley college in 1992, and she teaches courses in personality psychology, research methods, as well as a seminar on optimism and pessimism.
Two approaches to the study of personality traits 23. Defensive pessimism is a cognitive strategy identified by nancy cantor and her students in the mid1980s. In this article we discuss the strategies that people may use to cope with situations that are risky in that they present the possibility for failure and potential threats to selfesteem. The difference between dispositional and defensive pessimism is that defensive pessimism. Furthermore, in the specific area of learning optimism amongst children, there have been eleven replications, of which eight replicated the results, whilst three found no effects. I recently spoke with norem, a pioneer of the defensive pessimism theory. Studies have found that the defensive pessimism cognitive strategy. Pessimism is the tendency to expect a poor or unfavorable outcome. Defensive pessimism, anxiety, and the complexity of. But some 30 to 35 percent of americans employ a calculated form of negative thinkingcalled defensive pessimismthat can lead to very positive results, according to julie k. Those who use the strategy feel anxious and out of control as they think about an upcoming situation. Defensive pessimism definition defensive pessimism is a strategy people can use to manage their anxiety. Article pdf available in journal of personality and social psychology 516.
Defensive pessimism is a motivated cognitive strategy that helps people manage their anxiety and pursue their goals. Myers ap is a trademark registered andor owned by the college board, which was not involved in the production of, and does not endorse, this product. We found that their results are likely due to scale artefact item valence. Reflection and distraction defensive pessimism, strategic optimism.
Grasha university of cincinnati in two experiments, several personality attributes evident in metaphors people use to describe everyday experiences were examined. Defensive pessimism in legal education ssrn papers. Revised neo personality inventory neopir and neo fivefactor inventory neoffi professional manual. While some pessimism can actually be beneficial, too much can harm a persons mental health. Pessimism is definitely a poison to the roots of true happiness.
Individuals use defensive pessimism as a strategy to prepare for anxietyprovoking events or performances. The mental process by which one word or image may spontaneously suggest another without any apparent connection a psychoanalytic technique for investigation of the unconscious mind, in which a relaxed subject reports all passing thoughts without reservation. A motivational analysis of defensive pessimism and self. This book is the fruit of nearly twenty years work in the domain of practical psychology. Defensive pessimism, selfesteem and achievement goals. Through a wellrounded blend of theory, case studies, and the latest research, this text identifies the structures and processes of personality, traces personality. Optimism and defensive pessimism in risky situations 1 julie k. Distinguishing defensive pessimism from depression. Pessimism is associated with anxiety, depression, sleep disorders, hostility, high blood pressure, heart disease, and lifestyle or behavior choices that can be damaging to ones overall health and.
The defensive pessimist in this context is one who anticipates and worries about a poor result despite a prior good track record. Cervone and pervins, th edition provides uniquely uptodate. Her research has been published in top journals, such as the journal of personality and social psychology and books such as the handbook of personality and social psychology. Strategy dependent effects of reflecting on self and tasks. Journal of personality and social psychology copyright 1986 oy the american psychological association, inc. Journal of personality and social psychology, 516, 12081217. The conclusion considers the implications that defensive pessimism has for how people think about pessimism and. If you didnt know any better, you might say were a country that preaches optimism. The terms optimism and pessimism refer to the tendencies of people to expect that good things will happen and to expect that bad things will happen, respectively. Philosophical pessimism is the related idea that views the world in a strictly antioptimistic fashion.
Instead, it is a philosophy or worldview that directly challenges the notion of progress and what may be considered the faithbased claims of optimism. Cppa defensive pessimism implications for positive psychology. It does parody the positive psychology movement as a pollyannaish way of thinking. We use defensive pessimism research to illustrate that there are times when pessimism and. Marys university abstract two studies examined motivational in. A manual for the use of the motivated strategies for learning questionnaire mslq. Defensive pessimism, anxiety, and the complexity of evaluating selfregulation. Sep 12, 2014 i recently spoke with norem, a pioneer of the defensive pessimism theory.
However, the learned optimism programme as it stands may be more focused on stopping pessimism than enhancing optimism which is its own and different skill. Each dwarf has a distinct and dominant personality trait. Give me my parachute and i will at least feel a little better. Cambridge core institutional access books catalogue individuals. Jul 08, 2018 it feels a little awkward to admit that im a pessimist. Defensive pessimism, optimism, and pessimism request pdf. Relationships between defensive pessimism, personality, and. Defensive pessimists lower their expectations to help prepare themselves for the worst. It grew gradually in my thoughts, taking shape from the countless impressions and experiences of a psychiatrist in the treatment of nervous illnesses, from intercourse with men and women of all social. This form of pessimism is not an emotional disposition as the term commonly connotes.
Probably the best way to read this book is to read it alongside something like learned optimism by martin seligman and to personalise the mixture of realistic optimism and constructive pessimism that suits you. Article information, pdf download for reflection and distraction defensive pessimism, strategic. Imagine you divided everyone in the world into two psychological groups. Philippe halsan jump book 4 personality an individuals characteristic pattern of thinking, feeling, and acting, across time and situations. Defensive pessimism is a strategy used by people who are anxious about an upcoming event. Yet pessimist remains a term of abusean accusation of a bad attitudeor the diagnosis of an unhappy psychological state. Aug 12, 2015 psychoanalytic pessimism versus humanistic optimism. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Defensive pessimism is linked to more positive outcomes than disposi. We use defensive pessimism research to illustrate that there are times when pessimism and negative thinking are indeed positive psychology, as they lead to better performance and personal growth.
Optimism and pessimism psychology definition iresearchnet. Nov 28, 2012 her book on defensive pessimism, the positive power of negative thinking basic books was published in 2001. Defensive pessimism questionnaire wellesley college. A motivational analysis of defensive pessimism and selfhandicapping andrew j.
Theory and research significantly updates and expands on previous editions of this classic text. Additional gift options are available when buying one ebook at a time. Julie norem, author of the book the positive power of negative thinking, reports. The conspiracy against the human race by thomas ligotti, the trouble with being born by emil m. Journal of personality and social psychology, 51, 12081217. Some implications of optimism and defensive pessimism.
1434 717 659 334 1324 1538 1333 501 31 316 213 1398 1444 619 1427 553 201 1560 1230 1310 917 917 420 1164 1512 116 1111 1143 1270 301 1353 1226 678 595 705 624 925